
Margaritaville Hotel San Diego Gaslamp Quarter
Best for downtown nightlife, convention access, and being steps from Petco Park.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Margaritaville Hotel San Diego Gaslamp Quarter is a 4-star, family-friendly downtown hotel with an island-themed restaurant, rooftop pool deck and meeting spaces — great for visitors who want nightlife, Padres games, or convention access. Kona Kai Resort & Spa, a Noble House Resort is a 4-star Shelter Island waterfront resort with marina access, a private beach and on-site spa services — best for travelers who prefer a quieter, waterside stay with boating and beach access.
Updated · about 4 km apart

Best for downtown nightlife, convention access, and being steps from Petco Park.

Best for waterside relaxation, boating and private beach access on Shelter Island.
When Margaritaville Hotel San Diego Gaslamp Quarter wins: choose Margaritaville if you want to be in the middle of the Gaslamp Quarter for restaurants, nightlife, quick trolley access, Petco Park and downtown convention or meeting venues — and you value a large rooftop pool deck and easy urban access.
When Kona Kai Resort & Spa wins: choose Kona Kai if you want a quieter, marina-side property with private beach access, watersport rentals, on-site spa-style services and a resort layout that centers on waterfront relaxation and boating.
Bottom line: pick Margaritaville for a social, central downtown stay and event-friendly facilities; pick Kona Kai to trade downtown energy for a lower-key, waterfront resort experience with beach and marina amenities.
| Category | Margaritaville Hotel San Diego Gaslamp Quarter | Kona Kai Resort & Spa, a Noble House Resort |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Urban, lively, island-themed downtown hotel | Laid-back waterfront resort centered on marina and beach |
| Location | Gaslamp Quarter, steps from Petco Park and the Convention Center | Shelter Island waterfront, near Japanese Friendship Bell and marina |
| Size / rooms | 235 rooms across 10 floors, including 16 suites | Not published |
| Ages / audience | All ages; family-friendly (21+ to check in) | All ages; not adults-only |
| Pools / beach | Heated outdoor rooftop pool deck (4th floor) with poolside bar | Outdoor pool(s) plus private beach and marina-side access |
| Restaurants & bars | LandShark Bar & Grill, 5 o'Clock Somewhere Rooftop Bar, Margaritaville Coffee Shop | On-site dining and poolside/waterside bar(s) (supplier listing names not published) |
| Spa & wellness | No standalone spa; select rooms have in-room soaking/whirlpool tubs; 24-hour fitness center | Spa services, massage, hot tub, fitness center and wellness options listed |
| Known for | Largest rooftop pool deck in downtown San Diego and easy access to downtown attractions | Marina-side setting, private beach and watersport rentals |
| Event & meeting space | 13,000+ sq ft adaptable event space, multiple ballrooms and rooftop venue | Indoor meeting/banquet facilities available (details from supplier listing) |
| Pets & accessibility | Pet-friendly (dogs under 75 lb), wheelchair-accessible rooms available | Pet-friendly (charges apply) and wheelchair accessible facilities listed |
Margaritaville sits in the Gaslamp Quarter, a short walk to Petco Park, the Convention Center and dozens of restaurants and bars.
Pick Margaritaville if you want downtown walking access to sports, events and nightlife.
Kona Kai is located on Shelter Island with direct marina and shoreline access, a short drive from downtown.
Pick Kona Kai if you prefer a waterside location and quick access to boating or beach time.
Margaritaville offers a mix of standard, deluxe and several spa-style rooms and suites geared toward downtown stays.
Choose Margaritaville for a variety of room types close to downtown venues and a few in-room spa options.
Kona Kai’s room list emphasizes bay and marina views with several bay-view and marina-view guestrooms and junior suites.
Choose Kona Kai if you want rooms arranged around water views and suite options with marina or bay outlooks.
Margaritaville places its dining and drinking venues in the heart of the Gaslamp with a rooftop bar and an all-day restaurant.
If you want easy access to downtown restaurants, live music and a rooftop cocktail scene, Margaritaville is convenient.
Kona Kai offers resort-style dining and poolside/waterside bars suited to a calmer, marina-side pace.
Kona Kai is the better pick for calmer meals with bay or marina views rather than downtown bustle.
Margaritaville’s signature amenity is its large heated rooftop pool deck with skyline views and a poolside bar.
Choose Margaritaville for a social rooftop pool experience with downtown views.
Kona Kai’s signature draw is its marina-side setting and private beach access, plus watersport rentals.
Choose Kona Kai for beach access, boating and watersports right from the property.
Margaritaville combines a 24-hour fitness center with an active rooftop nightlife spot rather than a dedicated spa.
Margaritaville works for guests who want to stay active and enjoy downtown nightlife rather than a full spa program.
Kona Kai lists spa, massage, hot tub and salon services alongside fitness and wellness offerings.
Kona Kai is a stronger fit if you prioritize spa treatments and quieter evenings by the water.

Margaritaville — steps from Petco Park and the Convention Center with large meeting and rooftop event spaces.

Kona Kai — private beach, marina access and watersport rentals make it the pick for on-water activities.

Margaritaville — a heated rooftop pool deck with a dedicated poolside bar and live-music dining.

Kona Kai — waterfront setting, spa services and a resort layout focused on relaxation and views.
Margaritaville Hotel San Diego Gaslamp Quarter — it's a 3–5 minute walk to Petco Park and a short walk to the Convention Center.
Kona Kai Resort & Spa — the supplier listing includes a private beach and direct shoreline access; Margaritaville does not have on-site beach access.
Kona Kai lists spa, massage and salon services. Margaritaville does not have a standalone spa; it offers select Spa rooms with in-room soaking tubs and in-room treatments on request.
Yes. Both properties welcome guests of all ages and are not adults-only; Margaritaville requires the primary guest to be 21 or older to check in.
Explore how Margaritaville Hotel San Diego Gaslamp Quarter stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·